tobihagemann/apply-findings

Apply Findings

Apply evaluated findings from the conversation context. Findings must have been through /evaluate-findings first.

Step 1: Identify Findings

Collect all findings from the conversation context. Findings should have Verdict columns (Apply, Skip, Escalate) from /evaluate-findings.

If findings are unevaluated (raw output without verdicts), stop and say to run /evaluate-findings first.

Step 2: Apply in File Order

Group Apply findings by file path and apply in file order to minimize context switching. For each finding:

1. Read the full function or logical block at the referenced location
2. Verify the finding still applies to the current code
3. Make the fix
4. If the finding renames an identifier, search the file for all occurrences of the old name before marking the fix complete. The cited location is often only one of several references.

If a finding references code that has changed since it was generated (e.g., by a prior fix in this same run), re-assess whether it still applies. Skip if the code has diverged.

Step 3: Handle Escalated Findings

For findings with Escalate verdict, use AskUserQuestion to present the trade-offs and let the user decide. Include your technical recommendation alongside the options. When options differ on both scope/intent adherence (what the task was scoped to do) and technical merit (what's engineering-wise better), state both axes explicitly — don't silently fold scope concerns into the technical recommendation.

• Apply — make the change
• Skip — leave as-is
• Note for later — run the /note-improvement skill to capture it

Step 4: Handle Skipped Improvements

Do not surface findings skipped as false positives or subjective preferences. For findings skipped solely because they are pre-existing, out of scope, or disproportionate, use AskUserQuestion to ask whether the user wants to apply the improvement now or note it for later:

• Apply now — make the change inline
• Note for later — run the /note-improvement skill to capture it

Step 5: Report Results

Summarize what was applied, what was escalated, and what was skipped.

Then use the TaskList tool and proceed to any remaining task.

Rules

• Only edit files. Do not stage, build, or test.
• If two findings conflict (suggest opposite changes to the same code), skip both and report the conflict.