talont-org/implement-experiment

Implement Experiment Skill

Implement an experiment plan in an isolated git worktree. All experiment artifacts are created inside a single self-contained folder under research/. The worktree is left intact for the orchestrator to run the experiment, test, and merge separately.

This skill reads the experiment plan and follows its implementation phases. The plan specifies the directory layout, what scripts to write, what data to generate, and what environment to set up. This skill builds all of it.

When to Use

• As the implementation step of the research recipe (phase 2)
• After the experiment plan has been approved via GitHub issue

Arguments

/autoskillit:implement-experiment {plan_path}

{plan_path} — Absolute path to the experiment plan file (required). Scan tokens after the skill name for the first path-like token (starts with /, ./, or .autoskillit/).

Critical Constraints

NEVER:

• Implement without first exploring affected systems with subagents
• Implement in the main working directory (always use the worktree)
• Force push or perform destructive git operations
• Merge the worktree branch into any branch
• Delete or remove the worktree
• Run the full test suite — pytest with no args or targeting the entire repo (the orchestrator handles full test execution via test_check)
• Create experiment files outside the planned research/ subfolder
• Execute git merge commands (all branch content must be applied via git cherry-pick or git checkout <branch> -- <file>)
• Run subagents in the background (run_in_background: true is prohibited)

ALWAYS:

• Create a new worktree from the current branch
• Use subagents to deeply understand the codebase context BEFORE implementing
• Use model: "sonnet" when spawning all subagents via the Task tool
• Follow the implementation phases from the experiment plan
• Put all experiment artifacts in one self-contained research/ subfolder
• Commit per phase with descriptive messages
• Leave the worktree intact when done
• Write tests/test_{script_name}.py alongside each experiment script created in Step 4
• Run pytest --collect-only after creating tests to verify discovery before committing
• Read before editing: Before issuing an Edit call on any file, ensure you have issued a Read on that file earlier in this session. Claude Code rejects Edit on unread files — the retry wastes a full API turn at current context size. If you are uncertain whether a file was read, issue a targeted Read (offset + limit to the region you plan to edit) rather than risk an error.

Context Limit Behavior

If this skill hits the Claude context limit mid-execution, the headless session terminates with needs_retry=true in the tool response. The worktree remains intact on disk with all commits made up to that point.

The orchestrator should NOT retry this skill — retrying creates a brand-new worktree, discarding all partial progress. Instead, route to the next step (run-experiment) which can work with whatever was committed.

Workflow

Step 0 — Validate Prerequisites

1. Extract and verify the plan path using path detection: scan the tokens after the skill name for the first one that starts with /, ./, {{AUTOSKILLIT_TEMP}}/, or .autoskillit/ — that token is the plan path. Ignore any non-path words that appear before it. If no path-like token is found, treat the entire argument string as pasted plan content. Verify the resolved file exists before proceeding.
2. Read the experiment plan. Extract:
   • The experiment directory name (research/YYYY-MM-DD-{slug}/)
   • The planned directory layout
   • Implementation phases
   • Environment requirements (whether an environment.yml is needed)
   • What scripts and artifacts to create
3. Check git status --porcelain — if dirty, warn user.

Step 1 — Create Git Worktree

CURRENT_BRANCH=$(git rev-parse --abbrev-ref HEAD)
WORKTREE_NAME="research-$(date +%Y%m%d-%H%M%S)"
WORKTREE_PATH="../worktrees/${WORKTREE_NAME}"
git worktree add -b "${WORKTREE_NAME}" "${WORKTREE_PATH}"
WORKTREE_PATH="$(cd "${WORKTREE_PATH}" && pwd)"

# Record the base branch for reliable discovery:
mkdir -p "{{AUTOSKILLIT_TEMP}}/worktrees/${WORKTREE_NAME}"
echo "${CURRENT_BRANCH}" > "{{AUTOSKILLIT_TEMP}}/worktrees/${WORKTREE_NAME}/base-branch"

# Set upstream tracking if possible:
REMOTE=$(git remote get-url upstream >/dev/null 2>&1 && echo upstream || echo origin)
if ! git fetch "$REMOTE" "${CURRENT_BRANCH}" 2>/dev/null; then
    echo "NOTE: Branch '${CURRENT_BRANCH}' has no remote tracking ref on $REMOTE."
fi
if ! git -C "${WORKTREE_PATH}" branch --set-upstream-to="${REMOTE}/${CURRENT_BRANCH}" "${WORKTREE_NAME}" 2>/dev/null; then
    echo "NOTE: Could not set upstream tracking for '${WORKTREE_NAME}' → '$REMOTE/${CURRENT_BRANCH}'."
fi

Step 1 (cont.) — Emit Structured Tokens Early

Immediately after the worktree is created, output these tokens so the execution layer can capture them even if context is exhausted later:

IMPORTANT: Emit the structured output tokens as literal plain text with no markdown formatting on the token names. Do not wrap token names in **bold**, *italic*, or any other markdown. The adjudicator performs a regex match on the exact token name — decorators cause match failure.

worktree_path = ${WORKTREE_PATH}
branch_name = ${WORKTREE_NAME}

Step 2 — Deep Context Understanding (Subagents)

Before implementing anything, launch subagents (model: "sonnet") to understand the codebase context needed for the experiment. The following are minimum required — launch as many additional subagents as needed.

Minimum subagents:

Subagent A — Codebase Context:

Understand the code areas the experiment will interact with. Identify APIs, data structures, functions, and modules that experiment scripts will need to reference or call. Report imports, interfaces, and patterns the scripts should follow.

Subagent B — Compute Environment Requirements:

Assess the compute environment needed to execute the experiment. Determine what system-level tools, libraries, or runtime capabilities the experiment requires. If the experiment plan specifies an environment.yml, examine it — identify any non-standard dependencies that need system packages installed alongside the micromamba environment. Report what the Dockerfile or container setup needs to provide beyond the base micromamba image.

Additional subagents (launch as many as needed):

• Deeper exploration of specific code areas referenced in the plan
• Understanding specific APIs, types, or interfaces the scripts will use
• Any other codebase investigation needed to write correct experiment code

Step 3 — Write Environment Artifacts

The environment is already prepared by setup-environment (upstream in the recipe). Read env_mode from context to understand what environment was provisioned (docker, micromamba-host, or unavailable). This step writes the Dockerfile template and environment.yml into the worktree as reproducibility artifacts — it does NOT build or install anything.

3a — Write the Dockerfile:

Locate the environment.yml in the planned research directory. The YAML's name: field is the MAMBA_ENV slug (e.g., 2026-04-13-my-experiment).

Write ${RESEARCH_DIR}/Dockerfile based on the canonical template at src/autoskillit/assets/research/Dockerfile.template in the project root, substituting ${MAMBA_ENV} with the actual environment name from environment.yml:

FROM mambaorg/micromamba:1.0-bullseye-slim
SHELL ["/bin/bash", "-c"]
ARG MAMBA_ENV="{slug}"

USER root
RUN apt-get --allow-releaseinfo-change update \
    && apt-get install -y --no-install-recommends procps git curl build-essential \
    && apt-get clean -y && rm -rf /var/lib/apt/lists/*

RUN curl -sL https://taskfile.dev/install.sh | sh -s -- -b /usr/local/bin

RUN rm -f /root/.bashrc \
    && echo "source /etc/container.bashrc" >> /etc/bash.bashrc \
    && echo "set +u" > /etc/container.bashrc \
    && echo 'eval "$(micromamba shell hook --shell=bash)"' >> /etc/container.bashrc

ENV BASH_ENV=/etc/container.bashrc
ENV ENV=/etc/container.bashrc

COPY {slug}.yaml /opt/research/env/
RUN micromamba create -f /opt/research/env/{slug}.yaml && micromamba clean -afy
RUN echo "micromamba activate {slug}" >> /etc/container.bashrc

3b — Write ${RESEARCH_DIR}/Taskfile.yml:

version: '3'
vars:
  SLUG: "{slug}"
  IMAGE: "research-{{.SLUG}}"
  RESEARCH_DIR:
    sh: pwd

tasks:
  run-experiment:
    desc: Run experiment inside container (volume-mounts research dir)
    cmds:
      - docker run --rm -v "{{.RESEARCH_DIR}}:/workspace" {{.IMAGE}} bash -c "cd /workspace && python scripts/run.py"
    dir: "{{.RESEARCH_DIR}}"

  test:
    desc: Run pytest test suite inside container
    cmds:
      - docker run --rm -v "{{.RESEARCH_DIR}}:/workspace" {{.IMAGE}} bash -c "cd /workspace && pytest tests/ -v"
    dir: "{{.RESEARCH_DIR}}"

Adjust the run-experiment command to match the actual entry-point script from the experiment plan.

3c — Write environment.yml and note env_mode:

If the experiment plan specifies an environment.yml, write it to ${RESEARCH_DIR}/environment.yml. This file is committed to the worktree as a reproducibility artifact — reviewers can inspect exact dependency versions.

Note the env_mode from context (set by setup-environment):

• docker — a container image was pre-built; run-experiment will execute inside it
• micromamba-host — a host environment was created; run-experiment will use micromamba run
• unavailable — no environment could be provisioned; run-experiment will emit blocked_experiment
• none — standard environment, no special setup needed

Do NOT invoke any container or environment construction commands. The environment is already ready.

All commands from this point must run from ${WORKTREE_PATH}. Use absolute paths to avoid CWD drift across Bash tool calls.

Step 4 — Implement Phase by Phase

Follow the implementation phases from the experiment plan. The plan specifies what to create in each phase. Typical phases include:

1. Directory structure and environment — create the research/ subfolder layout. If the plan specifies an environment.yml, create it and build the environment with micromamba.
2. Data generation — create data generation scripts, generate datasets, verify data properties.
3. Experiment scripts — create measurement, benchmark, and analysis scripts. Verify they compile/run.
4. Dry run — execute the experiment with minimal inputs to verify the pipeline works end-to-end.

For each phase, begin implementation immediately (no announcement):

1. Implement the changes
2. Run any verification the plan specifies
3. Commit with a descriptive message. If the project has pre-commit hooks, run pre-commit run --all-files and stage any auto-fixed files before each commit.

Test creation (required alongside each script phase):

When implementing experiment scripts in Phases 2 and 3, also create a corresponding tests/test_{script_name}.py for each script:

1. Create {WORKTREE_PATH}/research/{slug}/tests/ and conftest.py if not yet present
2. For each script (e.g., analysis.py), create tests/test_analysis.py covering:
   • Data loads without error and has the expected shape/type
   • Key output values fall in expected ranges (sanity checks, not exact match)
   • At least one test per public function or entry point
3. Run pytest --collect-only {WORKTREE_PATH}/research/{slug}/tests/ to confirm pytest can discover all test files. Fix any import errors before committing.

The plan is the authority on what phases exist and what each phase creates. Follow it.

Step 5 — Copy Experiment Plan into Research Folder

Copy the experiment plan into the research folder for reference:

RESEARCH_DIR=$(ls -d "${WORKTREE_PATH}"/research/*/ 2>/dev/null | head -1)
cp "${PLAN_PATH}" "${RESEARCH_DIR}experiment-plan.md"
git -C "${WORKTREE_PATH}" add research/ && git -C "${WORKTREE_PATH}" commit -m "Add experiment plan to research folder"

Step 6 — Pre-commit Checks (Conditional)

Pre-commit is only relevant when the worktree has a .pre-commit-config.yaml. Research worktrees do not — skip pre-commit for them.

if [ -f "${WORKTREE_PATH}/.pre-commit-config.yaml" ]; then
    cd "${WORKTREE_PATH}" && pre-commit run --all-files
    # Fix any formatting or linting issues, then re-stage and re-commit.
else
    echo "No .pre-commit-config.yaml found — skipping pre-commit (research worktree)."
fi

Step 7 — Handoff Report

Output to terminal:

• Worktree path: ${WORKTREE_PATH}
• Branch name: ${WORKTREE_NAME}
• Base branch: the branch the worktree was created from
• Research folder: the research/ subfolder created inside the worktree
• Summary: list of implemented phases and artifacts created

Explicitly state: "Worktree left intact for orchestrator to run experiment and test."

Then emit these structured output tokens:

IMPORTANT: Emit the structured output tokens as literal plain text with no markdown formatting on the token names. Do not wrap token names in **bold**, *italic*, or any other markdown. The adjudicator performs a regex match on the exact token name — decorators cause match failure.

worktree_path = ${WORKTREE_PATH}
branch_name = ${WORKTREE_NAME}

Error Handling

• Worktree creation fails — check git worktree list, suggest git worktree prune
• Environment build fails — report the error, suggest fixes to environment.yml
• Script creation fails — report which phase and why, offer to fix/retry or abort. Do NOT clean up the worktree.
• Pre-commit fails — fix formatting/linting issues and re-commit