spences10/tdd

Test-Driven Development

Drive implementation through tests using the red-green-refactor cycle.

Adapted from Matt Pocock's TDD skill

Trigger Patterns

• "use TDD"
• "TDD this feature"
• "red-green-refactor"
• "test-driven"
• "write tests first"

Do not activate for general "write tests for X" or "add test coverage" requests. This skill is specifically for the TDD workflow where tests lead implementation.

Philosophy

Test behavior, not implementation. Every test should verify what the code does from the outside, not how it works inside. See deep-modules.md for the reasoning behind this.

Good tests act as a contract: they define what the module promises to its callers. If you can swap the internals completely and your tests still pass, they're testing the right thing.

Workflow

1. Plan the Interface

Before writing any code, decide the public surface area:

• What functions/methods/endpoints will exist?
• What are the inputs and outputs?
• What are the edge cases and error conditions?

Design for the caller, not the implementation. See interface-design.md.

2. Write a Tracer Bullet Test

Start with one test that exercises the simplest meaningful path through the feature. This test should:

• Call the public API as a real consumer would
• Assert the most basic expected output
• Fail — because the implementation doesn't exist yet

RED: test exists, code does not

Run the test. Confirm it fails for the right reason (missing function, wrong return value — not a syntax error).

3. Make It Green

Write the minimum code to pass that one test. Do not write more than what the test demands. Hardcode return values if that's all it takes. The goal is a green test suite, not elegant code.

GREEN: test passes with minimal implementation

4. Refactor Under Green

With the test passing, clean up. Remove duplication, improve names, extract helpers — but only while tests stay green. See refactoring.md.

REFACTOR: improve code quality, tests still pass

5. Repeat

Add the next test. Pick the next simplest behavior that isn't covered. Follow the same cycle:

1. Write a failing test
2. Make it pass with minimal code
3. Refactor while green

Build up complexity incrementally. Each cycle should take minutes, not hours.

6. Handle Edge Cases

After the core behavior works, add tests for:

• Invalid inputs and error conditions
• Boundary values
• Empty/null/undefined cases
• Concurrent access if relevant

7. Final Refactor

Once all behavior is covered, do a final pass:

• Look for patterns across tests — consolidate setup with helpers
• Check that test names clearly describe the behavior being verified
• Ensure no test depends on another test's state
• Review implementation for unnecessary complexity

When to Mock

Use real dependencies when practical. Mock only at system boundaries — network calls, databases, file systems, clocks. See mocking.md for detailed guidance.

Test Quality

Write tests that are readable, independent, and fast. See tests.md for patterns on naming, structure, and assertion style.

Anti-patterns

• Writing implementation before the test (defeats the purpose)
• Writing multiple tests before making any pass (too much red)
• Skipping the refactor step (accumulates mess)
• Testing private methods or internal state
• Making tests pass by weakening assertions
• Mocking everything instead of testing real behavior

References

• deep-modules.md - Why to test surface area, not internals
• interface-design.md - Contract-first design
• mocking.md - When and how to use test doubles
• refactoring.md - Safe refactoring under green tests
• tests.md - Test structure, naming, and assertions