narumiruna/imrad-structure-detector

IMRaD Structure Detector

Purpose

Determine whether a task or source material is suitable for IMRaD treatment.

When to use

Use this skill when the user:

• Asks whether IMRaD should be applied
• Provides fragmented material and needs structure diagnostics
• Needs a go/no-go decision before IMRaD generation

When NOT to use

Do NOT use this skill when:

• The user explicitly asks for full IMRaD writing now
• The task is purely stylistic editing
• The task is unrelated to research-style analytical structure

Core Tasks

• Evaluate IMRaD applicability
• Detect section availability for Introduction, Methods, Results, Discussion
• Classify each section as explicit, partial, inferable, or unavailable
• Identify assumptions required to proceed
• Recommend full IMRaD, partial IMRaD, or no IMRaD

Decision Rules

Use IMRaD only when ALL are true:

• A clear question or problem exists
• A method exists or can be reasonably inferred
• Results exist or can be responsibly scoped as non-empirical
• Interpretation is needed

Lower applicability when the task is simple Q&A, tutorial content, or brainstorming without a meaningful method-result path.

Output Requirements

The output MUST include:

• IMRaD applicability: high, medium, or low
• Section availability:
  • Introduction
  • Methods
  • Results
  • Discussion
• Inferred components
• Key assumptions required
• Recommendation:
  • use full IMRaD
  • use partial IMRaD
  • do not use IMRaD

Truthfulness Constraints

• The agent MUST NOT claim missing empirical evidence exists
• Non-empirical results MUST be labeled as inferred, hypothetical, expected, or simulated
• The detector MUST diagnose only; it MUST NOT output a full IMRaD article

Failure Modes

• Over-triggering on simple explanatory tasks
• Treating unavailable evidence as observed results
• Giving a recommendation without assumptions
• Collapsing diagnosis into full drafting