jamie-bitflight/command-development

Command Development for Claude Code

Legacy Format Notice. The .claude/commands/ directory is a legacy format. For new development, use .claude/skills/<name>/SKILL.md instead. Both formats are loaded identically — the only difference is file layout. Use /plugin-creator:skill-creator for the preferred skills format.

Commands remain fully supported for backward compatibility and are still appropriate when maintaining existing command sets or contributing to projects that use the commands/ convention.

What Commands Are

Slash commands are Markdown files containing prompts that Claude executes when invoked via /command-name. They provide reusable, consistent, shareable workflows with quick access to complex prompts.

Commands are instructions FOR Claude, not messages TO users. When a user invokes /command-name, the command content becomes Claude's instructions. Write commands as directives to Claude about what to do.

<!-- Correct: instructions for Claude -->
Review this code for security vulnerabilities including:
- SQL injection
- XSS attacks
- Authentication issues

Provide specific line numbers and severity ratings.

<!-- Wrong: message to user — Claude receives this but has no directive -->
This command will review your code for security issues.
You'll receive a report with vulnerability details.

Command Locations

flowchart TD
    Q{"Where should the<br>command live?"}
    Q -->|"Shared with team"| Proj[".claude/commands/<br>Scope — this project only<br>Label — '(project)' in /help"]
    Q -->|"Personal use<br>across all projects"| User["~/.claude/commands/<br>Scope — all projects<br>Label — '(user)' in /help"]
    Q -->|"Bundled with a plugin"| Plugin["plugin-name/commands/<br>Scope — when plugin installed<br>Label — '(plugin-name)' in /help"]

File Format

Commands are .md files. No frontmatter is required for basic commands.

.claude/commands/
├── review.md           # /review
├── test.md             # /test
└── deploy.md           # /deploy

Add YAML frontmatter for configuration:

---
description: Review code for security issues
allowed-tools: Read, Grep, Bash(git:*)
model: sonnet
---

Review this code for security vulnerabilities...

Frontmatter Fields (Summary)

All fields are optional. Commands work without any frontmatter.

flowchart TD
    Start(["Writing command frontmatter"]) --> D{"Need a description<br>in /help?"}
    D -->|Yes| Desc["description — string, under 60 chars<br>Start with verb — Review, Deploy, Generate"]
    D -->|No| AT{"Need to restrict<br>tool access?"}
    Desc --> AT
    AT -->|Yes| Tools["allowed-tools — comma-separated or array<br>Bash(git:*) for filtered bash access"]
    AT -->|No| M{"Need a specific<br>model?"}
    Tools --> M
    M -->|Yes| Model["model — haiku, sonnet, or opus"]
    M -->|No| AH{"Command takes<br>arguments?"}
    Model --> AH
    AH -->|Yes| Hint["argument-hint — e.g. [pr-number] [priority]"]
    AH -->|No| DMI{"Should only user<br>invoke manually?"}
    Hint --> DMI
    DMI -->|Yes| Disable["disable-model-invocation — true"]
    DMI -->|No| Done(["Frontmatter complete"])
    Disable --> Done

For the complete field specification with examples, validation rules, and edge cases, see ./references/frontmatter-fields.md.

Dynamic Arguments

Positional Arguments

Capture individual arguments with $1, $2, $3:

---
description: Review PR with priority and assignee
argument-hint: [pr-number] [priority] [assignee]
---

Review pull request #$1 with priority level $2.
After review, assign to $3 for follow-up.

Running /review-pr 123 high alice expands to: Review pull request #123 with priority level high. After review, assign to alice for follow-up.

$ARGUMENTS

Capture all arguments as a single string:

---
argument-hint: [issue-number]
---

Fix issue #$ARGUMENTS following our coding standards.

File References with @

Include file contents using @ syntax:

Review @$1 for code quality and potential bugs.

Running /review-file src/api/users.ts causes Claude to read src/api/users.ts before processing the command.

Static references also work: Review @package.json and @tsconfig.json for consistency.

Bash Execution

Execute shell commands inline with !`command` syntax to gather dynamic context:

---
allowed-tools: Bash(git:*)
---

Files changed: !`git diff --name-only`

Review each file for code quality and potential bugs.

The command output replaces the placeholder before Claude processes the prompt. Ensure allowed-tools includes the appropriate Bash filter.

Command Organization

flowchart TD
    Q{"How many commands?"}
    Q -->|"5-15, no clear categories"| Flat["Flat structure<br>.claude/commands/*.md"]
    Q -->|"15+, clear categories"| NS["Namespaced structure<br>.claude/commands/ci/*.md<br>.claude/commands/git/*.md<br>.claude/commands/docs/*.md"]

Subdirectory names become namespaces shown in /help. For example, .claude/commands/ci/build.md appears as /build (project:ci).

Common Patterns

Review Pattern

---
description: Review code changes
allowed-tools: Read, Bash(git:*)
---

Files changed: !`git diff --name-only`

Review each file for:
1. Code quality and style
2. Potential bugs or issues
3. Test coverage
4. Documentation needs

Testing Pattern

---
description: Run tests for specific file
argument-hint: [test-file]
allowed-tools: Bash(npm:*)
---

Run tests: !`npm test $1`

Analyze results and suggest fixes for failures.

Workflow Pattern

---
description: Complete PR workflow
argument-hint: [pr-number]
allowed-tools: Bash(gh:*), Read
---

PR #$1 Workflow:

1. Fetch PR: !`gh pr view $1`
2. Review changes
3. Run checks
4. Approve or request changes

Best Practices

1. Single responsibility — one command, one task
2. Clear descriptions — self-explanatory in /help, under 60 chars
3. Document arguments — always provide argument-hint
4. Restrict tools — use most restrictive allowed-tools that works; prefer Bash(git:*) over Bash(*)
5. Consistent naming — use verb-noun pattern (review-pr, fix-issue)
6. Validate inputs — check for required arguments early in the prompt
7. Handle errors — consider missing or invalid arguments

Interactive Commands (AskUserQuestion)

For commands that need complex user input beyond simple arguments, use the AskUserQuestion tool. This enables multi-choice decisions, multi-select scenarios, and conditional workflows.

flowchart TD
    Q{"What kind of<br>user input?"}
    Q -->|"Simple values —<br>file paths, numbers"| Args["Use command arguments<br>argument-hint + positional vars"]
    Q -->|"Complex choices —<br>multiple options with trade-offs"| AUQ["Use AskUserQuestion<br>Include in allowed-tools"]
    Q -->|"Both"| Both["Arguments for known values<br>AskUserQuestion for decisions"]

For complete AskUserQuestion patterns including multi-stage workflows, conditional flows, multi-select, and validation loops, see ./references/interactive-commands.md.

Advanced Workflows

Commands can implement multi-step sequences, maintain state across invocations using .local.md files, coordinate with other commands, and compose into pipeline workflows.

For state management, command composition, workflow recovery, and error handling patterns, see ./references/advanced-workflows.md.

Plugin Command Features

Plugin commands have access to ${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT} for portable paths to plugin resources, auto-discovery from the commands/ directory, and can integrate with plugin agents, skills, and hooks.

For CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT patterns, plugin component integration, validation patterns, and marketplace distribution guidance, see ./references/plugin-command-patterns.md.

Troubleshooting

flowchart TD
    P{"What is the problem?"}
    P -->|"Command not appearing<br>in /help"| NotAppearing["Check file is in correct directory<br>Verify .md extension<br>Ensure valid Markdown format<br>Restart Claude Code"]
    P -->|"Arguments not<br>substituting"| ArgsNotWorking["Verify dollar-sign N syntax<br>Check argument-hint matches usage<br>Ensure no extra spaces"]
    P -->|"Bash execution<br>failing"| BashFail["Check allowed-tools includes Bash<br>Verify command syntax in backticks<br>Test command in terminal first<br>Check required permissions"]
    P -->|"File references<br>not loading"| FileFail["Verify @ syntax correct<br>Check file path is valid<br>Ensure Read tool allowed<br>Use project-relative paths"]

Related Skills

• For the preferred skills format: /plugin-creator:skill-creator
• For hook development: /plugin-creator:hooks-guide
• For agent creation: /plugin-creator:agent-creator
• For plugin lifecycle: /plugin-creator:plugin-lifecycle
• For plugin structure and component selection: /plugin-creator:component-patterns
• For command documentation and testing strategies: see ./references/frontmatter-fields.md validation section

Source: Adapted from Anthropic's plugin-dev:command-development skill (../claude-plugins-official/plugins/plugin-dev/skills/command-development/, 11 files).