edwinhu/dev-ralph-loop

Announce: "I'm using dev-ralph-loop to set up verification loops."

<EXTREMELY-IMPORTANT> ## Load TDD Enforcement (REQUIRED)

Before starting ANY ralph loop, you MUST load the TDD skill to remember the testing gates and task reframing:

Read ${CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR}/../../skills/dev-tdd/SKILL.md and follow its instructions.

This loads:

• Task reframing (your job is writing tests, not features)
• The Execution Gate (6 mandatory gates before E2E testing)
• GATE 5: READ LOGS (mandatory - cannot skip)
• The Iron Law of TDD (test-first approach)

Read dev-tdd skill content now before proceeding with ralph loops. </EXTREMELY-IMPORTANT>

Contents

• The Iron Law
• Per-Task Pattern
• Starting a Loop
• Inside the Loop
• Completing a Loop
• Example: Multi-Task Feature
• Rationalizations

Ralph Loop Pattern

<EXTREMELY-IMPORTANT> ## The Iron Law of Ralph Loops

ONE LOOP PER TASK. NOT ONE LOOP PER FEATURE. This is not negotiable.

A single feature-level loop provides ZERO per-task enforcement. You can just move to the next task without the loop actually gating anything.

Each task in PLAN.md gets its own ralph loop with its own completion promise. </EXTREMELY-IMPORTANT>

The Per-Task Pattern

For task N in PLAN.md (1, 2, 3, ...):
    1. Start ralph loop for task N
    2. Inside loop: spawn Task agents, iterate until done
    3. Output promise → loop ends
    4. Move to task N+1, start NEW ralph loop

Why per-task loops?

• Feature loops don't enforce task completion
• Without a loop per task, you can just... move on
• Each task needs its own completion gate
• The promise is your proof that the task is done

Starting a Loop

IMPORTANT: Avoid parentheses () in the prompt - they break zsh argument parsing. Use dashes or brackets instead.

For Implementation Tasks

Skill(skill="ralph-loop:ralph-loop", args="Task N: [TASK NAME] --max-iterations 10 --completion-promise TASKN_DONE")

For Debug Tasks

Skill(skill="ralph-loop:ralph-loop", args="Debug: [SYMPTOM] --max-iterations 15 --completion-promise FIXED")

Parameters

| Parameter | Purpose | Recommendation | |-----------|---------|----------------| | Prompt | What this loop is for | Be specific: "Task 2: Add auth service" | | --max-iterations | Safety limit | 10 for implementation, 15 for debugging | | --completion-promise | The completion gate | Unique per task: TASK1_DONE, TASK2_DONE, etc. |

Inside the Loop

Each iteration follows this pattern:

1. Spawn Task Agent

Task(subagent_type="general-purpose", prompt="""
[TASK-SPECIFIC INSTRUCTIONS]

Context:
- Read .planning/LEARNINGS.md for prior attempts
- Read .planning/SPEC.md for requirements
- Read .planning/PLAN.md for approach

Report back: what was done, results, any blockers.
""")

2. Verify Results

After Task agent returns:

• Check if the work is actually complete
• Verify tests pass (for implementation)
• Verify bug is fixed (for debugging)

3. Decide: Promise or Iterate

If complete: Output the promise

<promise>TASKN_DONE</promise>

If incomplete: Do NOT output promise. Spawn another Task agent to continue.

<EXTREMELY-IMPORTANT> ## Promise Rules

You may ONLY output the promise when the statement is COMPLETELY AND UNEQUIVOCALLY TRUE.

The promise is a claim that:

• For implementation: "This task's tests pass. The implementation is complete."
• For debugging: "The bug is fixed. Regression test passes."

You may NOT output the promise to:

• "Move on" to the next task
• "Try something else"
• Skip verification

If the promise isn't true, don't output it. Keep iterating. </EXTREMELY-IMPORTANT>

Completing a Loop

When you output the promise, the ralph loop ends. Then:

1. Update PLAN.md - Mark task complete:

   - [ ] Task N: Description  →  - [x] Task N: Description
   

2. Log to LEARNINGS.md - What was done, any discoveries
3. Immediately start next task's loop - Same response, no pause

<EXTREMELY-IMPORTANT> ## The Iron Law of Progression

After outputting a promise, you MUST start the next task within the SAME RESPONSE.

Not "should". Not "recommended". MUST.

| If you're about to... | Instead... | |----------------------|------------| | End your response after a promise | Continue with next task's loop invocation | | Ask "should I continue?" | Just continue | | Summarize progress so far | Save it for when ALL tasks are done | | Wait for user acknowledgment | User doesn't need to acknowledge each task |

The only valid stopping points:

1. ALL tasks in PLAN.md are marked [x] complete
2. You hit a blocker that requires user input (be specific about what you need)
3. User explicitly interrupted

Finishing one task is NOT a stopping point. The user is waiting for the FEATURE, not status updates. </EXTREMELY-IMPORTANT>

Example: Multi-Task Feature

## Task 1: Create types
Skill(skill="ralph-loop:ralph-loop", args="Task 1: Create types --max-iterations 5 --completion-promise TASK1_DONE")

[Spawn Task agent → implements types]
[Verify: tsc --noEmit passes]

<promise>TASK1_DONE</promise>

[Update PLAN.md: - [ ] Task 1 → - [x] Task 1]
[Log to LEARNINGS.md]
[IMMEDIATELY continue to Task 2 - same response]

## Task 2: Add service method
Skill(skill="ralph-loop:ralph-loop", args="Task 2: Add service method --max-iterations 10 --completion-promise TASK2_DONE")

[Spawn Task agent → implements method]
[Verify: tests fail → iterate]
[Spawn Task agent → fixes tests]
[Verify: tests pass]

<promise>TASK2_DONE</promise>

[Update PLAN.md: - [ ] Task 2 → - [x] Task 2]
[Log to LEARNINGS.md]
[IMMEDIATELY continue to Task 3 - same response]

## Task 3: Add route handler
Skill(skill="ralph-loop:ralph-loop", args="Task 3: Add route handler --max-iterations 10 --completion-promise TASK3_DONE")

[Spawn Task agent → implements route]
[Verify: integration test passes]

<promise>TASK3_DONE</promise>

[Update PLAN.md: - [ ] Task 3 → - [x] Task 3]
[Log to LEARNINGS.md]

## All tasks complete - NOW you can stop

Rationalization Prevention

These thoughts mean STOP—you're about to skip enforcement:

| Thought | Reality | |---------|---------| | "One loop for the whole feature" | NO. One loop PER TASK. Feature loops don't enforce. | | "I'll just move to the next task" | Did the current task's loop complete? If no loop, no gate. | | "Per-task loops are overhead" | Per-task loops are the ONLY enforcement. | | "Ralph is for hard problems" | Ralph is for ALL tasks. Simple tasks need gates too. | | "I'll iterate without the loop" | Without ralph, you'll declare done prematurely. | | "The ceremony isn't worth it" | The ceremony IS the value. It prevents shortcuts. | | "I'll cherry-pick the parts I need" | Skills are protocols, not menus. Follow all of it. | | "Tests passed on first try, skip loop" | Still need the loop structure. Lucky ≠ verified. | | "Task done, let me check in" | NO. Update PLAN.md, then start next task immediately. | | "User might want to review" | User wants ALL tasks done. Keep going. | | "Natural pause point" | Only pause when ALL tasks complete. | | "I'll update PLAN.md later" | NO. Update it NOW, right after the promise. | | "PLAN.md is just documentation" | PLAN.md is the source of truth. Keep it current. | | "Should I continue?" | YES. Don't ask. Just continue to the next task. |

Each task needs its own ralph loop. One feature loop provides ZERO per-task enforcement.

After outputting a promise: (1) Update PLAN.md, (2) Log to LEARNINGS.md, (3) Start next task's loop. All in the same response.

When NOT to Use Ralph Loops

Ralph loops are for:

• Implementation tasks (dev-implement)
• Bug fixes (dev-debug)

Ralph loops are NOT for:

• Exploration (dev-explore)
• Design (dev-design)
• Data science (ds uses output-first verification instead)
• Review phases (dev-review, ds-review)

Visual Tasks

For tasks that produce rendered visual output (slides, charts, UI), use visual-verify instead of a plain ralph loop. Visual-verify wraps the ralph-loop pattern with render → look-at → fix steps:

Read ${CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR}/../../skills/visual-verify/SKILL.md and follow its instructions.

Integration

This skill is invoked by:

• dev-implement - for standard implementation tasks
• dev-debug - for bug investigation and fixes
• visual-verify - wraps ralph-loop for visual output tasks

After all tasks complete, proceed to the next phase of the parent workflow.