edwinhu/bluebook

Bluebook 21st Edition Citation

Citation formatting for law reviews and legal scholarship per The Bluebook: A Uniform System of Citation (21st ed. 2020).

Announce: “I’m using the bluebook skill for citation formatting.”

When to Use

Invoke this skill for:

• Formatting case citations (federal, state, foreign)
• Statutory and regulatory citations
• Secondary sources (books, articles, treatises)
• Short form citations (id., supra, hereinafter)
• Introductory signals and parentheticals
• Citation sentences vs. citation clauses

For legal writing style: Use /writing-legal skill (Volokh) For general writing: Use /writing skill (Strunk & White)

<EXTREMELY-IMPORTANT> ## IRON LAW #1: NO CITATION WITHOUT VERIFICATION

If you haven’t verified EVERY element of a citation, DO NOT write it.

Before writing ANY citation:

1. Verify case name spelling and procedural posture
2. Verify reporter volume and page numbers
3. Verify court and year
4. Verify pinpoint page exists

Guessing reporter volumes or page numbers is NOT HELPFUL — the user publishes with wrong citations that fail verification. Period. </EXTREMELY-IMPORTANT>

<EXTREMELY-IMPORTANT> ## IRON LAW #2: NO SHORT FORMS WITHOUT FULL CITATION FIRST

Id., supra, and hereinafter REQUIRE a preceding full citation.

Before using ANY short form:

1. Locate the full citation in the document
2. Verify no intervening citations (for id.)
3. Verify the supra reference is unambiguous

Using id. after intervening citations creates ambiguity. Delete and cite in full. </EXTREMELY-IMPORTANT>

<EXTREMELY-IMPORTANT> ## IRON LAW #3: FOOTNOTE VS. TEXT CITATION FORMAT

Law review citations use footnote format (Rule 1). Court documents use text format (Bluepages).

FOOTNOTE (law reviews):    Smith v. Jones, 500 U.S. 1, 5 (1991).
TEXT (court documents):    Smith v. Jones, 500 U.S. 1, 5 (1991)

FOOTNOTE (statutes):       18 U.S.C. § 1001 (2018).
TEXT (statutes):           18 U.S.C. § 1001 (2018)

If writing for a law review and using text format conventions, DELETE and reformat. </EXTREMELY-IMPORTANT>

The Gate Function

Before writing ANY citation:

1. IDENTIFY → What type of source? (case, statute, article, book)
2. LOCATE   → Find the correct rule in Bluebook
3. VERIFY   → Confirm ALL elements (volume, page, court, year)
4. FORMAT   → Apply correct typeface and punctuation
5. CHECK    → Does this match examples in the rule?
6. WRITE    → Only after steps 1-5

Skipping any step produces unreliable citations.

Rationalization Table - STOP If You Think:

| Excuse | Reality | Do Instead | |--------|---------|------------| | “I’m pretty sure that’s the volume” | Pretty sure = wrong | VERIFY with actual source | | “Id. is close enough” | Intervening cite breaks id. | Use full short form | | “This signal seems right” | Wrong signals mislead readers | CHECK rule 1.2 examples | | “The parenthetical isn’t needed” | Parentheticals explain relevance | ADD what the source says | | “I’ll fix the pinpoint later” | Pinpoints prove claims | ADD pinpoint NOW | | “Small caps isn’t that important” | Typeface is mandatory | APPLY correct typeface | | “This abbreviation is obvious” | Wrong abbreviations fail | CHECK tables T6, T10, T12 |

Red Flags - STOP Immediately If:

• “Let me guess the reporter volume” → NO. Verify the actual cite.
• “Id. probably works here” → NO. Check for intervening citations.
• “Supra will point them back” → NO. Verify the full citation exists.
• “I’ll use the common abbreviation” → NO. Use Bluebook tables.
• “Close enough on the page number” → NO. Exact pinpoints required.

Quick Reference: Common Citation Forms

Cases (Rule 10)

Full citation:
Brown v. Board of Education, 347 U.S. 483, 495 (1954).

Short form (same footnote or five footnotes with no intervening):
Id. at 496.

Short form (different footnote, no intervening):
Brown, 347 U.S. at 497.

Short form (intervening citations):
Brown v. Board of Education, 347 U.S. at 498.

Statutes (Rule 12)

Full citation:
42 U.S.C. § 1983 (2018).

Multiple sections:
42 U.S.C. §§ 1983-1985 (2018).

Short form:
§ 1983 or id. § 1984

Law Review Articles (Rule 16)

Full citation:
Cass R. Sunstein, *On the Expressive Function of Law*, 144 U. Pa. L. Rev. 2021, 2030 (1996).

Short form:
Sunstein, supra note 12, at 2035.

Books (Rule 15)

Full citation:
Richard A. Posner, Economic Analysis of Law 45 (9th ed. 2014).

Short form:
Posner, supra note 5, at 52.

Typeface Rules (Rule 2)

| Source Type | Law Review Format | |-------------|-------------------| | Case names | Italics: Brown v. Board | | Book titles | Small caps: ECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF LAW | | Article titles | Italics: On the Expressive Function | | Journal names | Small caps: U. PA. L. REV. | | Periodical names (non-consecutively paginated) | Italics: N.Y. Times | | Statutes | Roman: 42 U.S.C. § 1983 |

Introductory Signals (Rule 1.2)

| Signal | Meaning | Use When | |--------|---------|----------| | [no signal] | Direct support | Source directly states proposition | | See | Implicit support | Source supports but doesn’t directly state | | See, e.g., | One of several | Multiple sources support; citing representative | | Cf. | Analogous support | Source supports by analogy | | Compare ... with | Comparison | Sources illustrate through contrast | | See generally | Background | Source provides helpful background | | But see | Contradiction | Source contradicts proposition | | Contra | Direct contradiction | Source directly contradicts |

Signal Order (Rule 1.3)

Within a single citation sentence, signals appear in this order:

1. [no signal]
2. E.g.,
3. Accord
4. See
5. See also
6. Cf.
7. Compare
8. Contra
9. But see
10. But cf.
11. See generally

Common Errors Checklist

Case Citations

• [ ] Party names shortened properly (omit “Inc.”, “Ltd.” unless only identifier)
• [ ] “United States” abbreviated to “U.S.” (as party, not “United States of America”)
• [ ] Reporter abbreviation matches T1
• [ ] Court identifier included unless obvious from reporter
• [ ] Year is decision year, not argument year
• [ ] Pinpoint included for specific propositions

Statutory Citations

• [ ] Current official code used (not session laws for current statutes)
• [ ] Section symbol (§) used, not “Section”
• [ ] Space between § and number
• [ ] Year is code edition year, not enactment year
• [ ] Supplements cited when applicable

Short Forms

• [ ] Full citation appears earlier in same document
• [ ] Id. used only when no intervening citation
• [ ] Supra refers to footnote number where full cite appears
• [ ] Hereinafter defined in first full citation

Progressive Disclosure

For detailed rules, consult:

Reference Files

• references/cases.md - Complete case citation rules (R. 10)
• references/statutes.md - Statutory and regulatory citations (R. 12-14)
• references/secondary-sources.md - Books, articles, treatises (R. 15-17)
• references/short-forms.md - Id., supra, hereinafter rules (R. 4)
• references/signals-parentheticals.md - Signals, parentheticals, order (R. 1)
• references/audit-patterns.md - Citation audit patterns and validation
• references/abbreviations.md - Bluebook abbreviation tables

NotebookLM Integration

For edge cases, ambiguous rules, or additional context beyond the reference files, query the Bluebook 21e (2020) notebook:

# Notebook ID: f70a9976-b443-43d5-b5fd-43ff86b2b700

# Query specific Bluebook rules
/Users/vwh7mb/projects/nlm/nlm generate-chat f70a9976-b443-43d5-b5fd-43ff86b2b700 “How do I cite an unpublished opinion under Rule 10.8.1?”

# Get rule clarification
/Users/vwh7mb/projects/nlm/nlm generate-chat f70a9976-b443-43d5-b5fd-43ff86b2b700 “What are the typeface conventions for treaty citations?”

# Verify abbreviation tables
/Users/vwh7mb/projects/nlm/nlm generate-chat f70a9976-b443-43d5-b5fd-43ff86b2b700 “What is the correct abbreviation for ‘Environmental’ in journal names per Table T13?”

When to query the notebook:

• Rule wording is ambiguous in reference files
• Formatting international or specialized materials
• Checking obscure abbreviations not in quick reference
• Resolving conflicts between rules
• Understanding historical changes from previous editions

When to Load References

Load the specific reference when:

• Formatting an unfamiliar source type
• Encountering edge cases (unpublished cases, foreign sources)
• Checking state-specific reporter requirements
• Working with complex statutory schemes
• Formatting international materials

Integration

Use with /writing-legal for complete legal scholarship workflow:

1. /bluebook formats citations correctly
2. /writing-legal ensures argument structure and evidence handling
3. /ai-anti-patterns catches AI writing indicators before submission

Why Skipping Hurts the Thing You Care About Most

| Shortcut | Consequence | |---|---| | Guessing citation format to save time | You guessed the citation format to save time. The footnote is wrong — your guess undermines the paper's credibility. | | Skipping verification of reporter/volume | You cited without checking the reporter. The cite is to the wrong volume — your laziness is visible to every reader. | | Using short form without establishing full citation first | You used a short form before the full citation. The reader can't trace the source — your shortcut created confusion. |

Delete & Restart Pattern

When to delete and restart:

1. Citation uses guessed page numbers → Delete, verify source, cite with real numbers
2. Id. follows intervening citation → Delete id., use full short form
3. Wrong signal used → Delete, reread Rule 1.2, apply correct signal
4. Typeface incorrect → Delete, apply Rule 2 typeface
5. Abbreviation doesn’t match Bluebook tables → Delete, use table abbreviation

How to restart:

Old: See Smith v. Jones, 500 U.S. at 15. Id. at 20. [intervening cite] Id. at 25.
New: See Smith v. Jones, 500 U.S. at 15. Id. at 20. [intervening cite] Smith, 500 U.S. at 25.

The third cite cannot use id. after an intervening citation.