drillan/review-pr-comments

/review-pr-comments

Review and respond to PR review comments.

Usage

/review-pr-comments [pr-number]

Arguments

| Argument | Type | Required | Description | |----------|------|----------|-------------| | pr-number | integer | No | GitHub PR number (auto-detect from current branch if omitted) |

Instructions

When the user invokes /review-pr-comments, follow these steps:

Step 1: Determine PR Number

If PR number is provided:

• Use the provided number

If not provided:

• Get current branch name
• Find PR for this branch:

  gh pr list --head <branch-name> --state open --json number --limit 1
  

Step 2: Fetch Comments

gh api repos/{owner}/{repo}/pulls/<number>/comments

Parse and group comments by thread/file.

Step 3: Display Comment Table

Present comments in a table format:

| Thread ID | File | Issue | Decision | Action |
|-----------|------|-------|----------|--------|
| PRRT_xxx | src/auth.py:10 | "Fix null check" | ? | - |
| PRRT_yyy | src/user.py:20 | "Consider error handling" | ? | - |

Step 4: Process Each Comment

For each comment, ask the user:

1. Accept - Make the suggested change
2. Reject - Reply with reason and resolve thread
3. Discuss - Reply asking for clarification
4. Skip - Leave for later

Step 5: Execute Actions

For accepted comments:

• Make the code changes
• Reply to thread: "Fixed in <commit-hash>"
• Resolve the thread

For rejected comments:

• Reply with reason provided by user
• Resolve the thread

Step 6: Create Summary

Post a summary comment on the PR:

## Review Response Summary

### Accepted (2)
- [src/auth.py:10] Fixed null check
- [src/user.py:20] Added error handling

### Rejected (1)
- [src/api.py:5] Reason: Current approach is intentional for...

### Pending (0)
None

---
*Reviewed by Claude Code at YYYY-MM-DD HH:MM*

Step 7: Commit Changes

If changes were made:

git add .
git commit -m "address review comments"

Output Format

Comment List

## PR #100 - Review Comments

### Unresolved Comments (3)

| # | File | Line | Comment | Author |
|---|------|------|---------|--------|
| 1 | src/auth.py | 10 | "Add null check" | @reviewer |
| 2 | src/auth.py | 25 | "Consider edge case" | @reviewer |
| 3 | src/user.py | 15 | "Rename variable" | @lead |

For each comment, choose:
[A]ccept | [R]eject | [D]iscuss | [S]kip

Error Handling

| Error | Action | |-------|--------| | PR not detected | No PR found for current branch | | PR not found | Display error message | | No comments | No review comments found | | API error | Display error details |

Tips

• Use --web to open PR in browser for context:

  gh pr view <number> --web
  

• Group related comments and address them together
• Explain rejections clearly to avoid back-and-forth