casemark/plea-agreement

Plea Agreement

Drafts an enforceable plea agreement formalizing the negotiated resolution of criminal charges between defendant and prosecution, compliant with Fed. R. Crim. P. 11 or state equivalents.

Prerequisites

Gather before drafting:

• Case info — case number, court, presiding judge, full caption
• Charge sheet — all original charges with statute citations and max penalties
• Negotiated terms — plea charges, dismissed charges, sentencing concessions
• Factual basis — agreed facts establishing each element of plea offense(s)
• Defendant info — full legal name, aliases, DOB
• Cooperation terms (if any) — debriefing, testimony, ongoing obligations

Quick Start

1. Collect all prerequisites above
2. Identify agreement type (Rule 11(c)(1)(A), (B), or (C); or state equivalent)
3. Draft sections in order below
4. Run through the pitfalls checklist before finalizing

Document Sections

Draft these sections in order:

1. Parties & Jurisdiction

| Field | Content | |-------|---------| | Defendant | Full name, aliases/AKAs, DOB, case number | | Prosecution | Office (USAO / DA), assigned prosecutor | | Court | Name, district/division, presiding judge | | Jurisdictional basis | Statutory authority |

2. Charges & Plea Specification

• Table all original charges: count number, statute, offense, max penalty
• Table plea charges: counts defendant pleads to (guilty or nolo contendere)
• List dismissed/not-pursued charges
• If charge reduction: state both original and reduced charge explicitly
• Include voluntariness statement

3. Factual Basis

Stipulated facts establishing every element of each plea offense. Must cover:

• Date, time, location of offense
• Defendant's conduct constituting the crime
• Victims, co-conspirators, relevant parties
• Mental state / intent as required by statute
• Aggravating or mitigating circumstances relevant to sentencing

Write so defendant can acknowledge as true. This stipulation binds defendant and may be used in subsequent proceedings.

4. Sentencing Recommendations

Identify the agreement type:

| Type | Effect | |------|--------| | Rule 11(c)(1)(A) | Charge dismissal / non-prosecution agreement | | Rule 11(c)(1)(B) | Non-binding recommendation — court may reject | | Rule 11(c)(1)(C) | Binding sentence — defendant may withdraw if court rejects |

For state cases, cite the equivalent rule.

Include as applicable: incarceration/probation recommendation, fines, restitution and payment schedule, supervised release conditions, forfeiture terms, guideline calculations, departure/variance positions, government sentencing posture, defendant's right to request different sentence.

5. Rights Waived & Retained

Waived:

• Jury trial and confrontation of witnesses
• Privilege against self-incrimination
• Compulsory process for defense witnesses
• Appeal (specify scope: sentence, conviction, or both)
• Post-conviction relief (specify exceptions: ineffective assistance, prosecutorial misconduct)
• Speedy Trial Act rights

Retained:

• Challenge illegal sentence
• Challenge voluntariness of plea
• Any other negotiated retained rights

Include confirmation defendant discussed waivers with counsel.

6. Additional Terms

Address as applicable:

• Cooperation obligations (testimony, debriefings, law enforcement cooperation)
• Related civil/administrative proceeding agreements
• Media contact restrictions
• Breach provisions — consequences for each party's breach
• Government's right to reinstate dismissed charges upon defendant's breach

7. Acknowledgments

Defendant affirms:

• Plea is voluntary — no force, threats, or undisclosed promises
• Reviewed agreement with counsel; understands all terms
• Satisfied with counsel's representation
• Understands charges and potential penalties
• Mentally competent; not under influence of substances
• Agreement constitutes entire understanding (integration clause)

8. Signature Blocks

Include signature lines with date fields for:

• Defendant — full name
• Defense counsel — name, bar number, certification that agreement was explained and plea is voluntary and knowing
• Prosecutor — name, title, office
• Judge — if required by local rules

Pitfalls & Checks

• [ ] Use plain language; retain terms of art only where legally necessary
• [ ] Number all paragraphs for cross-reference at plea colloquy
• [ ] Verify internal consistency — dismissed charges, retained rights, and breach provisions must align
• [ ] Confirm compliance with Fed. R. Crim. P. 11 (federal) or state equivalent plus local rules
• [ ] For state cases, adapt all Rule 11 references to applicable state rule
• [ ] Never include terms beyond what the parties actually negotiated
• [ ] Flag ambiguous sentencing terms — courts scrutinize vagueness at plea hearings
• [ ] For cooperation agreements, ensure defendant protections (use immunity, safe harbor provisions)