brycewang-stanford/review-paper
skills/14-luischanci-claude-code-research-starter/dot-claude/skills/review-paper/SKILL.md
Comprehensive manuscript review covering argument structure, identification strategy, econometric specification, citation completeness, and potential referee objections.
$ install --global
skillsauthnpx skillsauth add brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Agent-Skills-for-Empirical-Research review-paperInstall this skill globally with one command. Works with Claude Code, Cursor, and Windsurf.
Security Scan Results
3 of 9 scanners reported clean
Some scanners were skipped, did not run, or reported a non-clean status. Review each row below.
3
Scanners Passed
9
Scanners in report
Clean
TrivyContainer and dependency vulnerability scanner
95%
Clean
SemgrepStatic code analysis for vulnerabilities
95%
Clean
mcp-scan (Snyk)Model Context Protocol security validation
95%
Skipped
Snyk (dep)Open source security scanning
50%
Skipped
Socket.devSupply chain security analysis
50%
Skipped
VirusTotalMulti-engine malware detection
50%
Skipped
CrowdStrikeAdvanced threat intelligence
50%
Skipped
OSV-ScannerOpen Source Vulnerability database check
50%
Skipped
OWASP Dep-Check
50%
Last scanned: Apr 24, 2026, 8:34 PM0.4s1 file scanned
SKILL.md
- name:
- review-paper
- description:
- Comprehensive manuscript review covering argument structure, identification strategy, econometric specification, citation completeness, and potential referee objections.
- disable-model-invocation:
- true
- argument-hint:
- [paper filename in master_supporting_docs/ or path to .tex/.pdf]
- allowed-tools:
- ["Read", "Grep", "Glob", "Write", "Task"]
Review Paper
Produce a thorough referee-style review of an academic manuscript.
Steps
-
Identify the paper: Use
$ARGUMENTS. Checkmaster_supporting_docs/supporting_papers/or the paper folder. -
Evaluate across 6 dimensions (rate each 1-5):
- Argument Structure: Research question clarity, logical flow, evidence support, limitations acknowledged
- Identification Strategy: Causal claim credibility, identifying assumptions stated, threats discussed, robustness checks proposed
- Econometric Specification: Standard errors appropriate, functional form justified, sample selection discussed, multiple testing addressed, economic meaningfulness vs statistical significance
- Literature Positioning: Key citations present, accurate characterization, clear differentiation, missing citations identified
- Writing Quality: Clarity, tone, notation consistency, abstract quality, self-contained tables/figures
- Presentation: Table/figure design, notation consistency across sections, typos, paper length
-
Generate 3-5 likely referee objections with suggested responses.
-
Overall recommendation: Strong Accept / Accept / Revise & Resubmit / Reject.
-
Save report to
quality_reports/paper_review_[sanitized_name].md.
Notes
- Be constructive. Identify strengths alongside weaknesses.
- Distinguish CRITICAL (math wrong) from MAJOR (missing discussion) from MINOR (could be clearer).
Related Skills
brycewang-stanford/auto-review-loop-minimax
tools
Community
Autonomous multi-round research review loop using MiniMax API. Use when you want to use MiniMax instead of Codex MCP for external review. Trigger with "auto review loop minimax" or "minimax review".
3,665SKILL.mdUpdated May 26, 2026
brycewang-stanford/auto-review-loop-llm
tools
Community
Autonomous research review loop using any OpenAI-compatible LLM API. Configure via llm-chat MCP server or environment variables. Trigger with "auto review loop llm" or "llm review".
3,665SKILL.mdUpdated May 26, 2026
brycewang-stanford/auto-review-loop-minimax
tools
Community
Autonomous multi-round research review loop using MiniMax API. Use when you want to use MiniMax instead of Codex MCP for external review. Trigger with "auto review loop minimax" or "minimax review".
3,665SKILL.mdUpdated May 20, 2026
brycewang-stanford/auto-review-loop-llm
tools
VerifiedTrustedCommunity
Autonomous research review loop using any OpenAI-compatible LLM API. Configure via llm-chat MCP server or environment variables. Trigger with "auto review loop llm" or "llm review".
3,665SKILL.mdUpdated May 20, 2026