ariffazil/ARCHIVE-vault-integrity

Vault Integrity

REASONING PHILOSOPHY

VAULT999 is an append-only, hash-chained, immutable audit ledger. It is NOT a database. It is NOT a secret store. It is NOT a cache. Every write is permanent and cryptographically sealed. Think of it as a constitutional notary, not a storage bucket.

The vault exists to answer one question: "What happened, and can we prove it?" Every entry must be self-contained, verifiable, and meaningful to a future auditor who has zero context about the session that created it.

DECISION HEURISTICS

What belongs in VAULT999:

• 888 JUDGE verdicts (SEAL, SABAR, HOLD, VOID)
• 999 SEAL terminal anchors
• Epoch boundaries (session start/end)
• Constitutional state changes
• Irreversible forge operations with ack

What does NOT belong in VAULT999:

• Secrets, keys, tokens, passwords (use vault.env or Docker secrets)
• Routine operational logs (use system logs)
• Debug output or temporary state
• Personal notes or session memory (use /root/.claude/memory/)

When to verify the chain:

• Before appending: verify the last hash
• After appending: verify the new hash
• Suspicious activity detected: full chain audit

SIGNAL PRIORITY

1. Chain integrity (hash verification)
2. Entry completeness (all required fields present)
3. Entry meaning (future-auditor test)
4. Entry ordering (chronological correctness)

UNCERTAINTY PROTOCOL

• If chain verification fails → do NOT append. 888 HOLD.
• If entry format is ambiguous → do NOT seal. Request clarification.
• If vault is unreachable → buffer locally, retry, escalate if persistent
• If two entries conflict on ordering → trust hash chain, not timestamp
• Never write secrets to vault. If unsure whether something is a secret → it is.

FAILURE MODE REGISTRY

These are specific errors. Actively avoid them:

• Writing secrets to outcomes.jsonl (catastrophic — secrets become immutable)
• Skipping hash verification (breaks chain trust)
• Writing entries with insufficient context (future auditor cannot understand)
• Treating vault as general-purpose storage (dilutes audit trail)
• Deleting or modifying vault files directly (violates append-only contract)

SCOPE BOUNDARIES

Applies to:

• /root/.local/share/arifos/vault999/outcomes.jsonl (physical file, chattr +a)
• http://localhost:8100 (vault999 service)
• http://localhost:5001 (vault999-writer service)
• All SEAL, SABAR, HOLD, VOID verdict storage

Does NOT apply to:

• General file storage or document management
• Database operations (PostgreSQL tables outside vault_seals)
• Secret storage or credential management
• Session memory or agent conversation logs