GPTomics/bio-atac-seq-co-accessibility

Version Compatibility

Reference examples tested with: Cicero 1.20+, monocle3 1.3+, ArchR 1.0.2+, SCENIC+ 1.0+, pycisTopic 1.0+, Signac 1.13+, GenomicRanges 1.54+, GenomicInteractions 1.36+, BSgenome.Hsapiens.UCSC.hg38 1.4+.

Verify before use:

• R: packageVersion('<pkg>') then ?function_name to verify parameters
• Python: pip show <package> then help(module.function) to check signatures

If code throws unexpected errors, introspect the installed package and adapt rather than retrying.

Co-accessibility (cis-Regulatory Linkage)

"Which enhancers connect to which promoters in my scATAC data?" -> Use cell-to-cell variability in joint accessibility of nearby peaks to infer cis-regulatory connections without explicit RNA expression. Output is a peak-pair graph with co-accessibility scores; thresholding produces enhancer-gene candidate pairs.

• R: cicero::run_cicero(input_cds, genomic_coords) -> peak-pair connection scores
• R: ArchR::addCoAccessibility(proj) -> ArchR-internal Cicero wrapper
• Python: pycisTopic + SCENIC+ for network-level inference combining ATAC + RNA + motifs

Co-accessibility is NOT 3D contact; it's a statistical association based on cell-to-cell co-variation. Strong co-accessibility correlates with Hi-C/Micro-C contacts (~30-50% concordance) but is not equivalent.

What Co-accessibility Captures vs What It Doesn't

| Captures | Misses | |----------|--------| | Peak pairs that vary together across cell states | 3D physical contacts that don't vary in accessibility | | Cis-regulatory grammar within a cell type | Trans-chromosomal interactions | | Active enhancer-promoter pairs | Constitutive structural contacts | | Lineage-specific regulation | Developmental contacts that opened before scATAC sample | | Distance-decay biology of enhancer-promoter | Hub enhancers that contact many distal targets |

For physical contact, use Hi-C, Micro-C, or PCHi-C. Co-accessibility is the chromatin-only proxy.

Algorithmic Taxonomy

| Tool | Method | Input | Output | Strength | Fails when | |------|--------|-------|--------|----------|------------| | Cicero (Pliner 2018) | Graphical lasso on aggregated cell metacells | scATAC peak-cell matrix + cell trajectory | Peak-pair connection score (0-1) | Original, well-validated; integrates with Monocle3 | Slow on >50K cells; sensitive to alpha tuning | | ArchR getCoAccessibility | Cicero-based; uses ArchR's metacell aggregation | ArchR project | Same as Cicero | Built-in to ArchR pipeline; faster on large datasets | Tied to ArchR; same biology as Cicero | | SCENIC+ (Bravo 2023) | Multi-step: co-accessibility + motif scoring + RNA correlation | Multiome (ATAC + RNA) or paired | TF-driven enhancer-gene networks | Most comprehensive; multi-modal | Multiome data required; computationally heavy | | LinkPeaks (Signac) | Pearson correlation of accessibility with paired gene expression | Multiome | Peak-gene linkage score | Direct enhancer-gene from RNA correlation | Multiome-only; not pure ATAC | | GeneHancer / FANTOM5 / EpiMap | Bulk-derived enhancer-gene reference | None (database lookup) | Pre-computed enhancer-gene pairs | Comprehensive; published references | Cell-type-agnostic; may not match the biology of interest |

Methodology evolves; verify against Pliner 2018 (Cicero), Bravo 2023 (SCENIC+), Nasser 2021 (ABC model alternative for enhancer-gene), and current Hi-C concordance benchmarks.

How Cicero Works (Conceptually)

Cell-to-cell variability is too sparse for direct correlation. Cicero solves this via metacells:

1. Reduce dimensionality (UMAP from input).
2. Build k-NN graph of cells.
3. Aggregate k cells into metacells (default k = 50).
4. Compute correlation in accessibility across metacells, restricted to peak pairs within genomic_distance_max (default 500 kb cis).
5. Apply graphical lasso with regularization alpha to sparsify the correlation matrix.
6. Output: per-pair connection score; positive = co-variation, negative = anti-co-variation.

Connection thresholds typically 0.05-0.5; > 0.25 is high-confidence.

Per-Tool Failure Modes

Cicero -- alpha tuning shifts results

Trigger: Default alpha (sometimes computed automatically from data); custom alpha < 0.5 or > 5.

Mechanism: Alpha controls graphical lasso regularization. Too low: dense graph with many spurious connections; too high: sparse with biology missing.

Symptom: Connection count varies 10-100x across alpha sweeps.

Fix: Use Cicero's estimate_distance_parameter() to get data-driven alpha; verify connection count is biologically plausible (~10-50% of peaks have at least one strong connection).

Cicero -- metacell aggregation hides cell-type-specific connections

Trigger: Running Cicero on heterogeneous dataset spanning multiple cell types.

Mechanism: Metacells aggregate across cell types; connections that exist only in one cell type get diluted.

Fix: Run Cicero per-cluster separately; combine results with cluster annotations. Cell-type-specific connections often differ.

Cicero -- distance assumption

Trigger: Default genomic_distance_max=500000 (500 kb cis only).

Mechanism: Distal connections beyond 500 kb cis are excluded; trans-chromosomal entirely missed.

Fix: For specific use cases (e.g., gene desertless TADs), increase genomic_distance_max to 1 Mb or more. Trans connections require Hi-C, not co-accessibility.

SCENIC+ -- RNA scaling

Trigger: RNA-side dropouts in Multiome data.

Mechanism: SCENIC+ requires reasonable RNA quantification per cell. Sparse Multiome RNA with many zero genes causes correlation degradation.

Fix: Filter cells with insufficient RNA; aggregate cells if necessary. Multiome RNA should look comparable to standalone scRNA-seq.

LinkPeaks (Signac) -- Distance default

Trigger: Default LinkPeaks(..., distance=5e+05).

Mechanism: Same as Cicero; 500 kb cis only by default.

Fix: Same; widen if needed but trans not supported.

Decision Tree by Goal

| Goal | Tool | |------|------| | ATAC-only enhancer-promoter inference | Cicero | | ATAC-only inside ArchR ecosystem | ArchR getCoAccessibility | | Multiome (RNA + ATAC) enhancer-gene inference | LinkPeaks (Signac) for direct correlation; SCENIC+ for TF network | | TF-driven regulatory networks | SCENIC+ (requires Multiome) | | Comparison against Hi-C / Micro-C | Cicero output -> overlap with HiCCUPS loops | | Published reference enhancer-gene pairs | GeneHancer, FANTOM5, EpiMap (pre-computed lookup) | | Gene desertless distal regulation | Cicero with widened distance; or H3K27ac HiChIP |

Cicero Standard Workflow

Goal: Infer cis-regulatory peak-peak connections from a scATAC peak-cell matrix.

Approach: Build a Monocle3 CellDataSet, reduce dimensions via LSI + UMAP, aggregate cells into metacells, then run Cicero's graphical-lasso correlation across the cis window and threshold on connection score.

library(cicero); library(monocle3); library(GenomicRanges)

# Input: peak-cell binary matrix from Signac/ArchR (rows = peaks, cols = cells)
# Convert peaks to "chrN_start_end" format
peak_names <- paste0(seqnames(peaks), '_', start(peaks), '_', end(peaks))
input_cds <- new_cell_data_set(peak_matrix, cell_metadata=metadata,
                               gene_metadata=peak_metadata)

# Reduce dimensionality (UMAP from input)
input_cds <- detect_genes(input_cds)
input_cds <- estimate_size_factors(input_cds)
input_cds <- preprocess_cds(input_cds, method='LSI')
input_cds <- reduce_dimension(input_cds, reduction_method='UMAP',
                              preprocess_method='LSI')

# Build metacell-aggregated CDS
umap_coords <- reducedDims(input_cds)$UMAP
cicero_cds <- make_cicero_cds(input_cds, reduced_coordinates=umap_coords, k=50)

# Run Cicero with hg38 chrom sizes
genome_df <- data.frame(chr=seqnames(seqinfo(BSgenome.Hsapiens.UCSC.hg38)),
                        length=seqlengths(seqinfo(BSgenome.Hsapiens.UCSC.hg38)))
conns <- run_cicero(cicero_cds, genomic_coords=genome_df,
                    window=500000, sample_num=100)

# Filter to high-confidence connections.
# Threshold 0.25 is a Cicero-documentation working default; the optimal cutoff
# is dataset-dependent and is best calibrated against orthogonal Hi-C / HiChIP.
strong <- conns[conns$coaccess > 0.25, ]
cat(sprintf('Total conns: %d; strong (>0.25): %d\n', nrow(conns), nrow(strong)))

ArchR getCoAccessibility

library(ArchR)
proj <- loadArchRProject('ArchR_out')
proj <- addCoAccessibility(proj, reducedDims='IterativeLSI',
                          k=100, knnIteration=500,
                          maxDist=250000)               # 250 kb cis (wider than the 100 kb default)
co_acc <- getCoAccessibility(proj, corCutOff=0.5,       # Default 0.5 in ArchR; lower for more (calibrate against Hi-C/HiChIP)
                             returnLoops=TRUE)           # TRUE (default) -> GRanges loops object; FALSE -> DataFrame of peak-pair correlations

With returnLoops=TRUE (the default) ArchR returns the connections as a GRanges loops object compatible with GenomicInteractions for direct overlap with Hi-C loops; returnLoops=FALSE instead returns a DataFrame of peak-pair correlations.

Visualizing Connections

# As arc plot at a locus of interest
library(Gviz); library(GenomicInteractions)
# Cicero Peak1/Peak2 are chr_start_end strings; convert to chr:start-end for GRanges()
gi <- GenomicInteractions(anchor1=GRanges(sub('_(\\d+)_(\\d+)$', ':\\1-\\2', strong$Peak1)),
                          anchor2=GRanges(sub('_(\\d+)_(\\d+)$', ':\\1-\\2', strong$Peak2)),
                          counts=as.integer(strong$coaccess * 100))
track <- InteractionTrack(gi, name='co-accessibility')
plotTracks(track)

For genome-browser visualization with ArchR: plotPeak2GeneHeatmap() shows the peak-gene linkage matrix; plotBrowserTrack() overlays connections on tracks.

SCENIC+ TF-Driven Networks

SCENIC+ 1.0 runs as a Snakemake pipeline (CLI), not a single monolithic Python call. Prepare the inputs first (a pycisTopic cisTopic object, motif-enrichment results, and paired RNA AnnData), then scaffold and run the workflow:

# Scaffold the pipeline, then edit its config.yaml to point at the cisTopic object,
# motif-enrichment results, and GEX AnnData
scenicplus init_snakemake --out_dir scplus_pipeline/
snakemake --cores 16 --snakefile scplus_pipeline/Snakemake/workflow/Snakefile
# eRegulons (TF + target genes + linked enhancers) are written to the output MuData (scplusmdata.h5mu)

SCENIC+ is significantly more complex than Cicero; budget 1-2 days for setup. The benefit is that outputs are TF -> enhancer -> gene triples, not just peak-peak co-accessibility.

Cicero Alpha Mathematics

Trigger: Tuning Cicero's regularization parameter for the graphical lasso step.

Mechanism: estimate_distance_parameter() searches for the smallest distance-penalty scaling (Cicero's distance_parameter, called "alpha" here) such that, across random genomic windows, no more than ~5% of peak pairs beyond distance_constraint retain non-zero graphical-lasso entries and fewer than 80% of all entries are non-zero. This penalizes long-range co-accessibility so the graph sparsifies at biologically appropriate distance scales -- it is not a correlation-vs-distance regression slope.

Implementation: Cicero calls estimate_distance_parameter(cicero_cds, window=window, maxit=100, sample_num=100, genomic_coords=genome_df) over sample_num random windows and returns one distance_parameter per window; take the mean and pass it to generate_cicero_models(cicero_cds, distance_parameter=mean(...)). Supply genomic_coords explicitly -- its default is cicero::human.hg19.genome, wrong for an hg38 analysis.

When manual tuning helps: Very dense peaksets (>200k peaks) may need a higher distance_parameter to control false positives; very sparse (<10k peaks) may need a lower one to recover signal. Verify by running on a permutation / cell-label-shuffle negative control -- the expected outcome is ~0 strong connections (technical replicates should instead reproduce connections).

ABC Model Cross-Reference

For enhancer-to-gene linking with paired Hi-C/Micro-C, the canonical method is the ABC model (Fulco 2019, Nasser 2021), not Cicero. ABC computes ABC = (Activity_E * Contact_E,G) / sum_e(Activity_e * Contact_e,G); standardizes on combined ATAC + H3K27ac activity and Hi-C contact frequencies. ENCODE-rE2G (Gschwind et al 2023, bioRxiv) is the modern logistic-regression enhancer-gene link predictor.

See atac-seq/enhancer-gene-linking for full ABC and ENCODE-rE2G coverage. Cicero is the ATAC-only fallback when no Hi-C is available.

HiChIP H3K27ac as Orthogonal Anchor

| Decision | Action | |----------|--------| | Have Hi-C / Micro-C | Use ABC (atac-seq/enhancer-gene-linking) primary; Cicero as ATAC-only sanity check | | Have HiChIP H3K27ac | FitHiChIP loops (FDR < 0.05, count >= 5) primary; ABC + HiChIP intersection is high-confidence | | Have ATAC + H3K27ac, no 3D | ABC with average HiC fallback (Fulco 2019); document degraded performance | | Have only ATAC | Cicero (this skill); known concordance with Hi-C ~30-50% |

Cicero is appropriate when no 3D data exists; do not use Cicero in lieu of ABC when Hi-C/Micro-C are available.

Hi-C / Micro-C Concordance

| Hi-C concordance | Action | |-----------------|--------| | > 50% of strong Cicero connections overlap Hi-C loops | High-confidence; Cicero captures real 3D structure | | 30-50% | Standard; some 3D contacts don't vary in accessibility | | < 20% | Co-accessibility may not reflect contacts; lineage-specific contacts may be missing |

Goal: Quantify what fraction of strong Cicero connections are supported by Hi-C loop calls.

Approach: Import HiCCUPS loops as GenomicInteractions, build a parallel object from Cicero connections, then count anchor-anchor overlaps and report the percentage.

# Compare Cicero against published Hi-C loops
library(GenomicInteractions)
hic_loops <- makeGenomicInteractionsFromFile('hiccups_loops.bedpe', type='bedpe',
                                             experiment_name='hiccups', description='HiCCUPS loops')
ci <- GenomicInteractions(anchor1=GRanges(sub('_(\\d+)_(\\d+)$', ':\\1-\\2', strong$Peak1)),
                          anchor2=GRanges(sub('_(\\d+)_(\\d+)$', ':\\1-\\2', strong$Peak2)))
overlap <- countOverlaps(ci, hic_loops) > 0   # anchor-anchor 'any' overlap; 'equal' is too stringent at loop bin resolution
cat(sprintf('Cicero connections overlapping HiCCUPS loops: %.1f%%\n',
            100 * mean(overlap)))

Reconciliation

| Pattern | Likely cause | Action | |---------|--------------|--------| | Cicero many weak connections; ArchR few strong | Different alpha or aggregation | Standardize parameters | | LinkPeaks (Multiome) finds connections Cicero misses | LinkPeaks uses RNA expression as the anchor; Cicero is ATAC-only | Both valid; report intersection as high-confidence | | Co-accessibility doesn't match Hi-C in heterochromatin | Heterochromatic contacts are constitutive; co-accessibility needs variation | Expected; co-accessibility complements Hi-C | | SCENIC+ network has ENCODE-validated TFs but missing some | Motif database limited or RNA imputation missed | Expand motif database; integrate paired ChIP-seq if available |

Operational rule: Co-accessibility is a hypothesis generator. Validate with Hi-C, ChIP-seq, or experimental enhancer-promoter interaction (CRISPRi-FlowFISH).

Common Errors

| Error / symptom | Cause | Solution | |-----------------|-------|----------| | Cicero make_cicero_cds slow / crashes | k too high or cell count too large | Reduce k or subsample cells | | All connections near zero | alpha set too high | Use estimate_distance_parameter() | | Connection score > 1 reported | Bug in older Cicero versions | Update; check as.numeric(coaccess) for outliers | | ArchR getCoAccessibility "TileMatrix" error | Need PeakMatrix not TileMatrix | addPeakMatrix() first | | SCENIC+ install fails | Many heavy dependencies | Use the published Docker image | | Connection count varies wildly per run | Stochastic metacell aggregation | Set seed; or aggregate at higher k for stability | | LinkPeaks all NaN | RNA expression has too many zeros | Re-filter cells with sufficient RNA | | Peak names not matching | format mismatch (chr_start_end vs chr:start-end) | Standardize naming convention |

References

• Pliner HA et al 2018 Mol Cell 71:858 (Cicero)
• Granja JM et al 2021 Nat Genet 53:403 (ArchR getCoAccessibility)
• Bravo Gonzalez-Blas C et al 2023 Nat Methods 20:1355 (SCENIC+)
• Stuart T et al 2021 Nat Methods 18:1333 (Signac LinkPeaks)
• Nasser J et al 2021 Nature 593:238 (ABC model; alternative enhancer-gene)
• Fulco CP et al 2019 Nat Genet 51:1664 (CRISPRi-FlowFISH; gold-standard validation)
• Mumbach MR et al 2017 Nat Genet 49:1602 (HiChIP H3K27ac for enhancer-promoter)
• Boix CA et al 2021 Nature 590:300 (EpiMap; bulk enhancer-gene reference)

Related Skills

• atac-seq/single-cell-atac - scATAC preprocessing (input)
• atac-seq/consensus-peakset - Peak set used for connection inference
• atac-seq/motif-deviation - chromVAR for TF activity (complement)
• atac-seq/enhancer-gene-linking - ABC, ENCODE-rE2G, CRISPRi-FlowFISH validation when Hi-C is available
• atac-seq/deep-learning-atac - chromBPNet variant effect at predicted enhancers
• gene-regulatory-networks/scenic-regulons - Standalone SCENIC for TF networks
• hi-c-analysis/loop-calling - Physical contacts from Hi-C
• hi-c-analysis/contact-pairs - Hi-C / Micro-C contact pairs
• single-cell/multimodal-integration - Multiome integration
• chip-seq/peak-annotation - Cross-validate with TF ChIP
• pathway-analysis/gsea - Downstream gene-level enrichment